I'll have to cast my vote too on the side of not trying to make a 68 into a Judge clone. Pontiac People will instantly spot it and the less genteel won't be kind... If you're the sort of person who cares what other people think, it won't be pleasant.
However, if none of that bothers you and YOU really like it that way, then do it. You're paying the bills, you get to make the choices. It's quite possible to work oneself into a frenzied spiral from worrying about what other people think.